Home
Rudy Henkel [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
Rudy Henkel

[ website | My Website ]
[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
[ archive | journal archive ]

A Hitch in Hitchens: Arguments From the Turek-Hitchens Debate [Sep. 11th, 2008|10:03 am]
[Tags|, , ]

EDIT:  I will no longer be responding to challenges to my arguments from anonymous posters.  If you want me to take you seriously, take 30 seconds to create a free account.

I apologize for the delay on this second part, but I do have a job and such.  This is something I do out of a personal desire.

If you have not seen the precusor to this post, you should read it first.

In this section, I will be looking at some of the specific questions and arguments.  It will almost certainly be updated with more arguments and details.  I am not a journalist of any kind, and I was not taking notes.  Thus, I’m sure I’ve forgotten some things.  If so, please let me know, and I will do my best to address them.

To be clear, when I refer to “God,” I am referring to the general conception of a theistic god. 

The arguments... )

 


link106 comments|post comment

A Hitch in Hitchens: Observations From the Turek-Hitchens Debate [Sep. 10th, 2008|04:08 am]
[Tags|, , ]

The following is my personal opinion.  It does not reflect the official position of any group with which I am associated.  If you were there, and disagree with any aspect of my assessment, please let me know in comments.

 
I’m starting this in the wee hours of the morning after returning quite a distance from a debate between Christopher Hitchens and Frank Turek. The debate was hosted by the United Secular Alliance at VCU (Richmond, VA.)  Under consideration was, "Does God Exist?," with a twenty minute introduction from each debater, followed by a five minute rebuttal, a chance to ask their opponent three questions, questions from the audience, and finally a five minute concluding statement.

Now, let me first say that I am a Hitchens fanboy.  I have watched every video of his debates available online, read an awful lot of his material, and have a huge amount of admiration for him.  Several members of Maryland Atheist Outreach, Beltway Atheists and DC Atheist Women can testify to the fact that I was giddy as a schoolgirl waiting for the event to begin.  I shook hands with, and talked to Hitchens for a minute or two afterwards, and I will likely not wash that hand for a week.  Bear all of this in mind when I tell you that Hitchens' performance was, at best, disappointing.
 

I'll start with Turek... )

 
The second part of my analysis in now up.

link59 comments|post comment

navigation
[ viewing | most recent entries ]

Advertisement